Growing Up Kindle: Reading in the Digital Age

kindle2bluewatervisionflickr

I was reading an article on TechCrunch the other day about Disney’s newest venture into online reading. The comments, as per usual, varied in opinion, but one comment stood out to me:

It makes me wonder if books will exist in the same way that classical music and opera exist today, in that a fraction of the educated class finds it to be a refined, involved pleasure, which the rest of the world does not enjoy because those things have a learning curve.

Will reading tangible books be seen as a fad? Will they become outdated, prehistoric, in the way scrolls were once used, now disregarded? Looking back through history, people chose using the typewriter over handwritten letters due to its ease; the telephone became the source of communication due to its convenience. Now, email and texting has become the norm.

Then, musicians like Beethoven and Mozart were revered, and people waited for newspapers to publish popular novelist’s newest stories or chapters. Now, we idolize pop and rock stars while reading celebrity biographies (trust me, I’m not exempt from this). The world is evolving, yes, but there comes a point where you begin to wonder…

For those who know me, you should know my stance on this. I will be the one creating an entire library and hoarding books in secret hiding places in my attic à la Fahrenheit 451 to make sure books never disappear from my hands. And while I love products such as LeapFrog for helping kids learn how to read, I’m not sure how I would feel were digital to go mainstream.

Books are much more to me than a tool to learn. They are the open doors to other worlds, they are the gatekeeper to the imagination. Sure you can take a Kindle and laptop anywhere and read — and if one were traveling, I would advocate for exactly that. But there’s something about a book…something charming and nostalgic and inexplicable. Others have said you can’t curl up with a Kindle like you can a book; that old “books are your best friend” idea just doesn’t seem the same with an electronic device. For me, it doesn’t have the same old, familiar comfort.

I wonder, too, what the impact could be on the mind, if it’s possible that the brain processes information differently on the page verses on the screen. I wonder if our minds are so geared now for the fast-paced world of the computer that when we read on an electronic device, that sense of hyperactive processing somehow doesn’t slow. With a book, reading is almost leisurely, relaxing; it makes you take your time and contemplate as you delve deeper and deeper into the words, the ideas, the story, the content. It seems, with electronic devices, you remain at the surface level.

We seem to have gotten to the point where we want things to be quicker and easier, more convenient and all electronic. But I think there’s something to be said for holding a hardcover book in your hands, fingers poised on the corner, lightly touching the paper as you anticipate turning the page.

There’s something to be said for wanting to curl up in bed with your son or daughter and a familiar book as you tell them a fairy-tale and read them goodnight.

What are your thoughts on the advent of the digital age and its affect on books and future generations?


2 Comments so far

  1. Amanda Linehan October 6th, 2009 1:59 pm

    Hi Susan – It’s a little hard to imagine reading without a physical book in my hand. I’ve never tried the Kindle, but that’s not to say I’m not interested. I think “digital reading” will get more and more popular, but books will always have a place too. Like, we can all watch DVDs in our homes, but people still go to the movies. There’s just something about it. :)

  2. Susan Pogorzelski - admin October 6th, 2009 7:36 pm

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts, Amanda! I agree that I think books will survive — I think they are so deeply ingrained in our lives and society that it would be difficult for them not to be — but it really makes you wonder what the affect will be on not only the future, but future generations who are growing up with all this technology at their fingertips. Imagine — in just the past ten years our lives have changed dramatically due to technological advancements; it makes you wonder if there’s an impact on intelligence there as well.

    Good comparison to the DVDs and going to the movies…For awhile I wondered if books could be compared to the VHS, still around but rarely used until they become scarce and discarded. But yours seems more accurate — maybe it is a matter of preference.

    A lot to think about — thanks for your comment!

Leave a reply